Only 8% of HR leaders say their managers have the skills to use AI effectively. Meanwhile, managers are already making key decisions about performance, promotions, pay, and team workload using insights from AI-supported systems. These tools affect not only the decisions themselves but also how managers explain and justify them to employees.
As HR or L&D professionals, you may already notice the gap between your managers’ ability to interpret AI insights and the expectations placed on them. Your managers must analyze complex data, act on it accurately, and respond to questions about fairness and outcomes while learning these tools on the job. Some handle this with confidence, while others hesitate, defer decisions, or struggle to provide context.
Developing managers in this environment requires focusing on competencies that remain relevant even as systems evolve. These capabilities help your managers make sound decisions, communicate clearly, and lead teams consistently, even when recommendations come from different tools. In this blog, we discuss the core skills that define effective AI-era managers and how you can support their development.
What Changes in Day-to-Day Management
AI has changed how information enters the management workflow. Insights appear earlier, recommendations arrive with confidence, and patterns are highlighted automatically. Decisions that once unfolded gradually now feel immediate and more visible.
When your managers are comfortable in this environment, decisions move forward with a clear rationale. When confidence is still developing, hesitation appears in subtle ways. Managers may ask for confirmation more often, pause decisions that once felt routine, or rely on general language when explaining outcomes. Over time, these behaviors shape how your teams experience leadership and how secure managers feel in their roles.
The competencies below reflect what effective managers are already doing differently in organizations that are adapting well to AI-supported work.
Seven Core Competencies Every AI-Era Manager Needs
These seven skills shape how managers lead, make decisions, and communicate in AI-driven workplaces. They guide managers from uncertainty to confident action, helping your teams navigate complex situations while maintaining clarity, fairness, and consistency.
1. Practical Understanding of How AI Influences People’s Decisions
Your managers benefit from understanding where AI influences performance evaluations, workforce planning, and development discussions. This includes knowing what data informs recommendations, how those recommendations are framed, and where judgment is still required.
When this understanding is limited, managers may hesitate at decision points or lean heavily on system language when explaining outcomes. Conversations can feel incomplete, even when the decision itself is reasonable. Managers who understand how insights are generated tend to engage more confidently, add context, address questions directly, and make decisions they can explain without deferring responsibility.
For you, this highlights the need to develop how managers reason with AI, not just how they access it.
2. Leading Teams Through Ongoing Adjustment
As AI becomes part of everyday workflows, expectations and processes continue to shift. Your teams often sense these changes before they fully understand them and look to managers for direction.
When managers are unsure how to talk about change, communication slows. Updates become vague, or conversations are postponed until answers feel complete. Managers who handle adjustment well speak early, share what is known, and acknowledge what is still evolving. This steady communication helps your teams stay focused even when details continue to change.
The difference is not confidence in the technology but confidence in guiding people through uncertainty.
3. Applying Human Judgment With Awareness and Care
AI highlights patterns, but it cannot reflect personal circumstances, team dynamics, or emotional context. Managers remain responsible for interpreting information within the reality of your teams.
When judgment is underdeveloped, managers may default to metrics or struggle when employees question how outcomes were reached. Conversations can feel transactional or abrupt. Managers with strong judgment listen carefully, recognize when data tells only part of the story, and adjust their approach accordingly.
These moments are especially visible during performance conversations, workload discussions, and feedback that carries emotional weight.
4. Making Thoughtful Choices About Human and AI Contributions
Managers continually decide how work is divided between AI-supported processes and human effort. These decisions shape workloads, development opportunities, and how meaningful roles feel to your teams.
When this balance is unclear, teams may experience uneven expectations or confusion about priorities. Managers who revisit these decisions intentionally create clearer boundaries. Routine work flows more smoothly, and time is protected for collaboration, coaching, and problem-solving.
Consistency across teams matters here, which is where your guidance and support can have a significant impact.
5. Integrating Learning Into Everyday Work
Managers build confidence most effectively when learning connects directly to the decisions they are making in real time. Learning that sits outside daily work often struggles to influence behavior.
Managers who grow steadily reflect after decisions, compare approaches with peers, and apply insights immediately. When learning is embedded into work, development feels continuous rather than disruptive.
For you, this reinforces the value of timely support that meets managers where they are, rather than content delivered far from decision moments.
6. Using Data as Input, Not Instruction
AI-supported data can inform decisions, but managers remain accountable for outcomes. Interpreting data thoughtfully requires understanding its limits and balancing it with observation and feedback.
When managers rely on data alone, explanations can feel final rather than thoughtful. Employees may accept outcomes without understanding them. Managers who use data effectively explain how insights informed their thinking and where judgment played a role. This transparency strengthens credibility, especially when decisions are difficult.
This capability often shows up most clearly in how managers talk, not just in what they decide.
7. Upholding Ethical Use Through Clear Communication
As AI influences decisions about employees, questions about fairness and transparency surface naturally. Managers are often the first to be asked how AI-supported systems affect evaluations, monitoring, or advancement.
When managers feel unprepared for these conversations, responses can sound cautious or incomplete. Managers who communicate clearly explain how decisions are made, where human judgment applies, and how concerns can be raised. This clarity reduces uncertainty and reinforces trust.
Ethical competence shows up in everyday interactions, not just formal policies.
How You Can Support These Competencies: The D.E.C.I.D.E. Framework
L&D is most effective when it helps managers act with clarity, consistency, and accountability in real decisions. The DECIDE framework provides a structured approach to focus development and measure progress.
D: Decision Points
Identify key moments your managers regularly handle that involve AI-influenced inputs, such as promotions, pay adjustments, project assignments, and performance reviews. Target learning to these moments to improve the quality and consistency of decisions.
E: Explain Actions
Check whether managers can clearly explain how a decision was reached. This includes translating AI outputs into understandable reasoning, articulating trade-offs, and responding accurately to employee questions.
C: Consistency Checks
Observe patterns where decisions are delayed, escalated unnecessarily, or applied unevenly across teams. These behaviors reveal gaps in judgment, interpretation of AI data, or adherence to organizational standards.
I: In-Context Support
Provide resources managers can reference during actual work, such as brief guides, examples, or quick reference tools. Supporting managers in the workflow reinforces learning and ensures application.
D: Dialogue With Peers
Facilitate structured discussions where managers share approaches and review outcomes. Peer exchange helps surface blind spots, exposes common errors, and spreads effective practices across teams.
E: Evidence-Based Adjustment
Collect real-time input on challenges managers face. Track where decisions slow, questions arise, or patterns of misalignment appear. Use this information to continuously refine development programs and ensure relevance.
Trust KnowledgeCity to Build Manager Skills
Developing managers who lead with confidence in a technology-driven workplace requires learning that is practical, structured, and immediately applicable. KnowledgeCity’s learning library provides accredited and expertly curated courses that address the decisions your managers face every day.
Your managers gain the skills to interpret AI-driven insights, guide performance conversations, and act with clarity and consistency. Learning is applied in real time as part of daily work. This allows you to guide reflection, coaching, and peer discussions while ensuring development drives measurable results across your teams and organization.
KnowledgeCity 
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Join 80,000+ Fellow HR Professionals. Get expert recruiting and training tips straight
to your inbox, and become a better HR manager.